Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Giving every aspect 5 stars when writing a critique 

377 deviants said Only when the piece is truly amazing
227 deviants said Not really a critique
24 deviants said It's ok if you don't want to hurt someones feelings
14 deviants said Other

Devious Comments

WorldWar-Tori Featured By Owner Jun 20, 2012   General Artist
Only if it's in the top .021392 percent of most amazing things I've seen.
Picsonthewall Featured By Owner Jun 10, 2012
Only if it's a truly amazing piece of work, something that wows people in every aspect when they look at it.
illusionality Featured By Owner Jun 8, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Not a critique. Nothing is "perfect". No matter how great it looks. One can say: OMG its perfect!!11!1! , but in reality it isnt.
Emerald-Depths Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That's not a critique. I critique is meant to help the artist see potential issues in their work and should also help them improve. "Criticism" is fault-finding, therefore a critique should be used to point out problems.
Sodayaka Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012  Student Digital Artist
I don't really think it's possible to make a 'perfect' work of art. A critique to me is meant to give helpful tips, pointers and another perspective on the piece, not fawning over it. I'm not saying it's pointless to do it, but I think that is meant for the masters in a specific craft.
John-234 Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012
I think it's dependent on your status as a reviewer and any precedent you set. Is five stars "no problems" or "perfect?"
Alternativeproject Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
i feel like that's a bit subjective. Somethings seem perfectly amazing to one person, and flawed to another. It just seems to depend, but it would have to a pretty well rounded work.
Leafbreeze7 Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012
Only if it's perfect, which is basically impossible, because everything is has a flaw. That's what makes it unique! :love:
lieveheersbeestje Featured By Owner Jun 7, 2012
Only when a piece is truly amazing :)
Add a Comment:

Poll History